Welcome to Crabby Amy's,
At Crabby Amy's, located right on the vibrant shores of Seaford, NY, the spirit of Long Island seafood dining comes alive. This charming eatery captivates with its signature dishes, from locally dug steamers to creamy seafood bisque. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, enhanced by friendly service and stunning views of the marina. Regulars rave about the fresh, flavorful options, like the beloved fried seafood sampler and delicious tacos. Crabby Amy's is not just a restaurant; it's a community hub where every meal is a chance to celebrate seaside life. Don’t miss this gem for an authentic coastal experience.
-
2880 Ocean Ave, Seaford, NY 11783 Hotline: (516) 783-2554
Welcome to Crabby Amy's, a delightful seafood haven nestled at 2880 Ocean Ave in Seaford, NY. If you’re seeking an authentic coastal dining experience, look no further! With a stunning view of the waterfront, this charming eatery brings the quintessential Long Island vibe right to your table.
Crabby Amy's is all about celebrating the bounty of the sea, and their menu is a testament to that commitment. Start your day with their breakfast specialties, featuring options like 2 Eggs any Style with Home Fries and Toast for just $6.95. If you’re feeling a bit indulgent, the Bacon, Ham, and Sausage breakfast will set you back a mere $9.95, and both come with your choice of coffee or tea.
Dive into their rich array of soups and salads, with the Classic Caesar Salad and delightful Seafood Bisque, both priced at $6.95. For those looking to whet their appetite, the Whole Baked Clams ($7.95) and Locally Dug L.I. Steamers ($11.95) are standout choices that reflect the freshness and flavor of the region.
Here, dining is a lively experience, as reflected in the many customer reviews. Carol L. describes her meal as not just delicious but also complemented by excellent service. However, be wary of the pesky yellow jackets buzzing around during your visit! A frequent guest, Barry C., highlights the incredible taste of their fried seafood sampler, praising the generous portions and lower-than-expected prices, while Vinny B. enjoyed his Labor Day feast of littlenecks and a tuna wrap, all enjoyed by the docks.
- Highlight Dishes:
- Frozen Old Bay Steamed Shrimp: Some guests noted that these could use a flavor boost.
- Lobster Roll: Warm and well-received by customers.
- Fried Seafood Sampler: Praised for its generous portions and fresh taste.
- Atmosphere: The jovial ambiance pairs well with classic 70s music, making it a fun spot to unwind.
While not all feedback has been perfect—one patron noted issues with service and menu accuracy—many, like Kristy R., found the food delicious enough to forgive minor missteps. Patrons rave about the freshness and quality of the seafood, enhancing the waterfront dining experience. The ice-cold bottles of beer also elevate your meal, providing a refreshing companion to the robust flavors of the food.
Whether you’re a seafood aficionado or simply looking for a relaxing day by the water, Crabby Amy's has something for everyone. Just remember to bring some sunscreen if you plan to sit outside! With a friendly staff to guide you through their offerings, you're sure to have a memorable dining experience. So why not stop by and make some delicious memories today?
The food was delicious and service was excellent. The only issue was the yellow jackets.
Labor Day 24, great service ! Our waitress was in from Michigan helping the owner for the weekend and was Fantastic! Very busy and the wife n I scored high top by the docks. Doz littlenecks, plate of steamers, tuna wrap and ice cold beer great end to the long weekend moving daughter back to college in the city. Thanks Michigan friend from the VA. Couple.
We't for a nice casual dinner Sunday night. It was windy so I know no bugs will be around. I have been there before and it's been buggy. The bad first 1) Our waiter- he handed us menus and turned his back on us until I called him to take our order??? 2) I asked him for water and he brought out 3 cups of warm water??. I asked for some ice for our waters and he took my cup only and put ice in it ?? 3) He said he will put Tuna on a Caesar salad- I got Tuna on a tossed salad and a Caesar salad separate 3) You have to update your menu on line The GREAT news Food was amazing 2lbs of smaller very sweet Steamers No one has that ever Fried seafood sampler had a huge piece of flounder- the shrimps were plump and tasted great Tacos packed they actually made up one of each for us special the grilled shrimp was delicious The tuna was grilled perfectly Everything was amazing and the price was lower than expected We loved the 70"s music but I told the chief I need to hear some Dead when I go to a place like his. LOL
Our waitress was sweet the drinks were good but the food was lacking. The old bay steamed shrimp was very tough and had almost no flavor. Straight from the freezer. Out of lots of things. My husband enjoyed the lobster roll (warm) and the potato salad was great! The place is on the water with a view of the boats. Nice place on a sunny day. They offer a kids menu but unfortunately they were out of one of the three options. This place has so much potential and has a great vibe. We will be back again to check out the progress. Oh also the corn on the cob was awesome! Love places that have things like this! It doesn't come with old bay but ask for it and sprinkle it on it. Delicious. Edited: I replaced my shrimp with the chicken tacos, they had so much flavor and were delicious!
We ended up enjoying Crabby Amy's after almost becoming crabby ourselves. First there is no direct way of being seated here. Bunch of tables, some covered, others not and you just grab an empty one and wait and wait. No menus until a waitress finally noticed us waiting. She was apologetic and presented the menus. The offering is what you would expect from a seafood shack in a marina. Fried shrimp, clams, oysters, tacos, and beer. No bar here so just bottled beer but it is ice cold and hits the spot while you're sitting by the water. We both wanted clam strips and after a 20 minute wait our waitress said they ran out. Ugh. So we opted for the shrimp. She came back after and said the kitchen screwed up and they did indeed have clam! Hurrah! The day was saved! She felt so bad about the back and forth on our order that she ended up comping our next round of drinks, The food was fresh and delicious! They have big bottles of malt vinegar which help hit the spot with seafood and fries. Prices are fair for what you get and they accept credit.
Crabby Amy's is a fabulous little place right on the water. It gives you a classic Long Island vibe. The food is served very fast and the waiters and waitresses are so kind. Their specialty is the seafood however I don't like seafood so I went with the chicken tenders.(very adventurous of me, I know) They were amazing and very filling. We also got fries for the table which were tasty. There are many tables right on the water however many of those don't have shaded areas so don't forget to wear sunscreen and a hat! Enjoy!