Crabby Amy's, Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Crabby Amy's, a charming seafood haven located by the picturesque waterfront of Seaford, NY. Dive into a menu that champions freshness and flavor, with standout highlights including locally dug L.I. steamers and satisfying whole baked clams, perfect for those who crave authentic coastal bites.

Breakfast enthusiasts can savor hearty plates featuring eggs or a medley of meats, paired with delightful home fries and coffee. Indulge in a classic Caesar salad or rich seafood bisque as a prelude to your meal.

With an ambiance that celebrates the spirit of Long Island, Crabby Amy's also exudes warmth through its friendly service. Customers rave about the fried seafood sampler, featuring plump shrimp and flaky flounder, alongside unique tacos bursting with flavor. Whether you're a seafood lover or just seeking a taste of the shore, there's something here for everyone!